Blog

Monthly investing or one lump sum? What happened in each tracked fund

By ReturnKoto? Published Updated

We ran the same window both ways across every fund we track and counted which approach came out ahead, fund by fund.

These figures update themselves. Every number below is recalculated from NAV history each day, so this page is current as of 16 November 2026 rather than the day it was written.

The usual advice is that investing monthly protects you from bad timing. The usual counter is that markets rise more often than they fall, so putting money in earlier tends to win. Both arguments are reasonable and neither settles anything.

We can just count.

The count

Across 38 funds over 2 years, a single lump sum at the start produced the higher annualised result in 16 funds. Monthly investing produced the higher result in 22.

Over this particular window, monthly investing came out ahead in 22 of 38 funds. That is a fact about this window, not a law.

Here is every fund, both ways. Each row is one fund; the two dots are the two methods over the same months, as a return per year.

  1. VIPB Fixed Income21.23% 19.85%: one-time 21.23% a year, monthly 19.85% a year
  2. Ekush Growth19.16% 19.55%: one-time 19.16% a year, monthly 19.55% a year
  3. Ekush First18.65% 19.18%: one-time 18.65% a year, monthly 19.18% a year
  4. EDGE Bangladesh18.94% 18.59%: one-time 18.94% a year, monthly 18.59% a year
  5. EDGE AMC Growth18.89% 17.81%: one-time 18.89% a year, monthly 17.81% a year
  6. Ekush Stable Return15.92% 15.55%: one-time 15.92% a year, monthly 15.55% a year
  7. Shanta Fixed Income14.48% 15.77%: one-time 14.48% a year, monthly 15.77% a year
  8. UCB Income Plus15.70% 14.41%: one-time 15.70% a year, monthly 14.41% a year
  9. IDLC Balanced15.11% 15.53%: one-time 15.11% a year, monthly 15.53% a year
  10. CWT Opportunities13.77% 15.20%: one-time 13.77% a year, monthly 15.20% a year
  11. EDGE High Quality Income15.05% 13.39%: one-time 15.05% a year, monthly 13.39% a year
  12. BCB ICL Growth13.56% 14.60%: one-time 13.56% a year, monthly 14.60% a year
  13. ICL Balanced12.73% 13.98%: one-time 12.73% a year, monthly 13.98% a year
  14. CWT Sadharan Bima Growth13.29% 13.87%: one-time 13.29% a year, monthly 13.87% a year
  15. CWT Emerging Bangladesh First Growth13.53% 13.24%: one-time 13.53% a year, monthly 13.24% a year
  16. VIPB NLI 1st12.83% 13.45%: one-time 12.83% a year, monthly 13.45% a year
  17. VIPB Accelerated Income12.79% 13.28%: one-time 12.79% a year, monthly 13.28% a year
  18. VIPB SEBL 1st12.64% 13.12%: one-time 12.64% a year, monthly 13.12% a year
  19. VIPB Balanced12.69% 13.03%: one-time 12.69% a year, monthly 13.03% a year
  20. VIPB Growth12.55% 12.85%: one-time 12.55% a year, monthly 12.85% a year
  21. LB Gratuity Opportunities12.25% 12.69%: one-time 12.25% a year, monthly 12.69% a year
  22. IDLC Growth12.54% 10.33%: one-time 12.54% a year, monthly 10.33% a year
  23. Esquire ICL Apparel11.12% 12.51%: one-time 11.12% a year, monthly 12.51% a year
  24. LB Gratuity Wealth Builder7.93% 12.39%: one-time 7.93% a year, monthly 12.39% a year
  25. IDLC Income10.31% 10.54%: one-time 10.31% a year, monthly 10.54% a year
  26. LankaBangla 1st Balanced9.94% 9.75%: one-time 9.94% a year, monthly 9.75% a year
  27. Shanta First Income9.38% 9.37%: one-time 9.38% a year, monthly 9.37% a year
  28. EDGE Al-Amin Shariah Consumer8.93% 7.84%: one-time 8.93% a year, monthly 7.84% a year
  29. LankaBangla Al-Arafah Shariah7.21% 8.07%: one-time 7.21% a year, monthly 8.07% a year
  30. UCB AML First6.19% 6.37%: one-time 6.19% a year, monthly 6.37% a year
  31. IDLC AML Shariah6.34% 5.10%: one-time 6.34% a year, monthly 5.10% a year
  32. Shanta Amanah Shariah6.07% 4.73%: one-time 6.07% a year, monthly 4.73% a year
  33. HFAML Shariah1.60% 3.87%: one-time 1.60% a year, monthly 3.87% a year
  34. ICL INCTL Shariah3.37% 2.79%: one-time 3.37% a year, monthly 2.79% a year
  35. CWT Community Bank Shariah2.46% 1.88%: one-time 2.46% a year, monthly 1.88% a year
  36. HFAML-ACME Employees'0.94% 2.39%: one-time 0.94% a year, monthly 2.39% a year
  37. UCB Taqwa Growth1.26% 0.94%: one-time 1.26% a year, monthly 0.94% a year
  38. HFAML-0.32% 0.13%: one-time -0.32% a year, monthly 0.13% a year
Return per year over 2 years for every fund with both figures: one amount at the start (time-weighted) against equal amounts paid in every month (money-weighted). Dividends reinvested, through 16 November 2026. Each name links to the fund.
Return per year over 2 years: one-time against monthly, the leading figure in bold. Dividends reinvested, NAV history through 16 November 2026.
FundOne-timeMonthly
VIPB Fixed Income Fund (Income)21.23%19.85%
Ekush Growth Fund (Growth)19.16%19.55%
Ekush First Unit Fund (Balanced)18.65%19.18%
EDGE Bangladesh Mutual Fund (Growth)18.94%18.59%
EDGE AMC Growth Fund (Growth)18.89%17.81%
Ekush Stable Return Fund (Income)15.92%15.55%
Shanta Fixed Income Fund (Income)14.48%15.77%
UCB Income Plus Fund (Income)15.70%14.41%
IDLC Balanced Fund (Balanced)15.11%15.53%
CWT Opportunities Fund (Growth)13.77%15.20%
EDGE High Quality Income Fund (Income)15.05%13.39%
BCB ICL Growth Fund (Growth)13.56%14.60%
ICL Balanced Fund (Balanced)12.73%13.98%
CWT Sadharan Bima Growth Fund (Growth)13.29%13.87%
CWT Emerging Bangladesh First Growth Fund (Growth)13.53%13.24%
VIPB NLI 1st Unit Fund (Growth)12.83%13.45%
VIPB Accelerated Income Unit Fund (Income)12.79%13.28%
VIPB SEBL 1st Unit Fund (Growth)12.64%13.12%
VIPB Balanced Fund (Balanced)12.69%13.03%
VIPB Growth Fund (Growth)12.55%12.85%
LB Gratuity Opportunities Fund (Balanced)12.25%12.69%
IDLC Growth Fund (Growth)12.54%10.33%
Esquire ICL Apparel Fund (Growth)11.12%12.51%
LB Gratuity Wealth Builder Fund (Balanced)7.93%12.39%
IDLC Income Fund (Income)10.31%10.54%
LankaBangla 1st Balanced Unit Fund (Balanced)9.94%9.75%
Shanta First Income Unit Fund (Growth)9.38%9.37%
EDGE Al-Amin Shariah Consumer Fund (Balanced)8.93%7.84%
LankaBangla Al-Arafah Shariah Unit Fund (Balanced)7.21%8.07%
UCB AML First Mutual Fund (Balanced)6.19%6.37%
IDLC AML Shariah Fund (Growth)6.34%5.10%
Shanta Amanah Shariah Fund (Growth)6.07%4.73%
HFAML Shariah Unit Fund (Growth)1.60%3.87%
ICL INCTL Shariah Fund (Balanced)3.37%2.79%
CWT Community Bank Shariah Fund (Growth)2.46%1.88%
HFAML-ACME Employees' Unit Fund (Growth)0.94%2.39%
UCB Taqwa Growth Fund (Growth)1.26%0.94%
HFAML Unit Fund (Growth)-0.32%0.13%

What drives that outcome is the shape of the period, not the merit of either method.

A lump sum wins when a fund's NAV rises steadily from the day you invest, because every taka is exposed for the whole window. Monthly investing wins when the NAV dips partway through, because the later instalments buy units at the lower price.

So the 22 to 16 split is a description of the last 2 years in these funds. A window with a different NAV path can produce a different split.

The comparison nobody runs

Treating this as a real choice assumes a lump sum exists. For most savers it does not: income arrives monthly, and the actual decision is whether to buy units as the money arrives or hold it in a bank account until it accumulates.

That version of the question has a cost the table above cannot show. Money waiting to be invested earns the deposit rate, currently around 8.8% a year on an FDR, while it waits. Against the 21.23% the strongest fund produced and the -0.32% the weakest produced, waiting is neither obviously safe nor obviously costly. It depends entirely on which fund the money was eventually going to buy.

What the monthly figures assume

A fixed deposit of ৳5,000 on a regular schedule, units bought at the NAV in force at the time, dividends reinvested. The full table of what that produced in each fund is in the monthly investing post.

Over 2 years that adds up to ৳1,20,000 paid in. The strongest result was VIPB Fixed Income Fund at ৳1,45,695; the weakest was HFAML Unit Fund at ৳1,20,168.

Notice which comparison is larger. The best and weakest fund were 21.55 percentage points a year apart. Inside the same fund, the two methods differed by 0.92 points on average. Over this window, choosing the fund mattered far more than choosing how to pay into it.

What is not modelled

No tax, no platform charge, no spread between the buying and selling price. The fund's management fee is inside the NAV, so it is reflected. Figures run through 16 November 2026.

Common questions

Which method is better overall?

Neither, universally. Over this window monthly investing led in 22 of 38 funds and the lump sum in 16, but the result depends on the shape of the period rather than on one method being superior.

Does monthly investing reduce risk?

It spreads out the price you pay, which reduces the impact of investing everything on a single bad day. It does not protect against a fund falling over the whole period.

What monthly amount is modelled?

৳5,000, applied identically to every fund so the results stay comparable. You can run a different figure on the homepage.

Does the choice of fund matter more than the method?

Over this window, choosing the fund mattered far more than choosing the method. The strongest and weakest fund were 21.55 percentage points a year apart, against an average gap of 0.92 points between the two methods in the same fund.

Further reading on this site

Run these numbers on your own amount

Read next